<h2>CHAPTER X</h2>
<p>“<span class="smcap">She’s</span> a good
woman,” said Robina.</p>
<p>“Who’s a good woman?” I asked.</p>
<p>“He’s trying, I expect; although he is an old
dear: to live with, I mean,” continued Robina, addressing
apparently the rising moon. “And then there are all
those children.”</p>
<p>“You are thinking of Mrs. St. Leonard,” I
suggested.</p>
<p>“There seems no way of making her happy,”
explained Robina. “On Thursday I went round early in
the morning to help Janie pack the baskets for the picnic.
It was her own idea, the picnic.”</p>
<p>“Speaking of picnics,” I said.</p>
<p>“You might have thought,” went on Robina,
“that she was dressing for her own funeral. She said
she knew she was going to catch her death of cold, sitting on the
wet grass. Something told her. I reminded her it
hadn’t rained for three weeks, and that everything was as
dry as a bone, but she said that made no difference to
grass. There is always a moisture in grass, and that
cushions and all that only helped to draw it out. Not that
it mattered. The end had to come, and so long as the others
were happy—you know her style. Nobody ever thought of
her. She was to be dragged here, dragged there. She
talked about herself as if she were some sacred image. It
got upon my nerves at last, so that I persuaded Janie to let me
offer to stop at home with her. I wasn’t too keen
about going myself; not by that time.”</p>
<p>“When our desires leave us, says Rochefoucauld,” I
remarked, “we pride ourselves upon our virtue in having
overcome them.”</p>
<p>“Well, it was her fault, anyhow,” retorted Robina;
“and I didn’t make a virtue of it. I told her
I’d just as soon not go, and that I felt sure the others
would be all right without her, so that there was no need for her
to be dragged anywhere. And then she burst into
tears.”</p>
<p>“She said,” I suggested, “that it was hard
on her to have children who could wish to go to a picnic and
leave their mother at home; that it was little enough enjoyment
she had in her life, heaven knows; that if there was one thing
she had been looking forward to it was this day’s outing;
but still, of course, if everybody would be happier without
her—”</p>
<p>“Something of the sort,” admitted Robina;
“only there was a lot of it. We had to all fuss round
her, and swear that without her it wouldn’t be worth
calling a picnic. She brightened up on the way
home.”</p>
<p>The screech-owl in the yew-tree emitted a blood-curdling
scream. He perches there each evening on the extreme end of
the longest bough. Dimly outlined against the night, he has
the appearance of a friendly hobgoblin. But I wish he
didn’t fancy himself as a vocalist. It is against his
own interests, I am sure, if he only knew it. That American
college yell of his must have the effect of sending every living
thing within half a mile back into its hole. Maybe it is a
provision of nature for clearing off the very old mice who have
become stone deaf and would otherwise be a burden on their
relatives. The others, unless out for suicide, must, one
thinks, be tolerably safe. Ethelbertha is persuaded he is a
sign of death; but seeing there isn’t a square quarter of a
mile in this county without its screech-owl, there can hardly by
this time be a resident that an Assurance Society would look
at. Veronica likes him. She even likes his
screech. I found her under the tree the other night,
wrapped up in a shawl, trying to learn it. As if one of
them were not enough! It made me quite cross with
her. Besides, it wasn’t a bit like it, as I told
her. She said it was better than I could do, anyhow; and I
was idiot enough to take up the challenge. It makes me
angry now, when I think of it: a respectable, middle-aged
literary man, standing under a yew-tree trying to screech like an
owl. And the bird was silly enough to encourage us.</p>
<p>“She was a charming girl,” I said,
“seven-and-twenty years ago, when St. Leonard fell in love
with her. She had those dark, dreamy eyes so suggestive of
veiled mysteries; and her lips must have looked bewitching when
they pouted. I expect they often did. They do so
still; but the pout of a woman of forty-six no longer
fascinates. To a pretty girl of nineteen a spice of temper,
an illogical unreasonableness, are added attractions: the scratch
of a blue-eyed kitten only tempts us to tease her the more.
Young Hubert St. Leonard—he had curly brown hair, with a
pretty trick of blushing, and was going to conquer the
world—found her fretfulness, her very selfishness adorable:
and told her so, kneeling before her, gazing into her bewildering
eyes—only he called it her waywardness, her imperiousness;
begged her for his sake to be more capricious. Told her how
beautiful she looked when displeased. So, no doubt, she
did—at nineteen.”</p>
<p>“He didn’t tell you all that, did he?”
demanded Robina.</p>
<p>“Not a word,” I reassured her, “except that
she was acknowledged by all authorities to have been the most
beautiful girl in Tunbridge Wells, and that her father had been
ruined by a rascally solicitor. No, I was merely, to use
the phrase of the French police courts, ‘reconstructing the
crime.’”</p>
<p>“It may be all wrong,” grumbled Robina.</p>
<p>“It may be,” I agreed. “But why?
Does it strike you as improbable?”</p>
<p>We were sitting in the porch, waiting for Dick to come by the
white path across the field.</p>
<p>“No,” answered Robina. “It all sounds
very probable. I wish it didn’t.”</p>
<p>“You must remember,” I continued, “that I am
an old playgoer. I have sat out so many of this
world’s dramas. It is as easy to reconstruct them
backwards as forwards. We are witnessing the last act of
the St. Leonard drama: that unsatisfactory last act that merely
fills out time after the play is ended! The intermediate
acts were probably more exciting, containing ‘passionate
scenes’ played with much earnestness; chiefly for the
amusement of the servants. But the first act, with the
Kentish lanes and woods for a back-cloth, must have been
charming. Here was the devout lover she had heard of,
dreamed of. It is delightful to be regarded as
perfection—not absolute perfection, for that might put a
strain upon us to live up to, but as so near perfection that to
be more perfect would just spoil it. The spots upon us,
that unappreciative friends and relations would magnify into
blemishes, seen in their true light: artistic shading relieving a
faultlessness that might otherwise prove too glaring. Dear
Hubert found her excellent just as she was in every detail.
It would have been a crime against Love for her to seek to change
herself.”</p>
<p>“Well, then, it was his fault,” argued
Robina. “If he was silly enough to like her faults,
and encourage her in them—”</p>
<p>“What could he have done,” I asked, “even if
he had seen them? A lover does not point out his
mistress’s shortcomings to her.”</p>
<p>“Much the more sensible plan if he did,” insisted
Robina. “Then if she cared for him she could set to
work to cure herself.”</p>
<p>“You would like it?” I said; “you would
appreciate it in your own case? Can you imagine young
Bute—?”</p>
<p>“Why young Bute?” demanded Robina;
“what’s he got to do with it?”</p>
<p>“Nothing,” I answered; “except that he
happens to be the first male creature you have ever come across
since you were six that you haven’t flirted
with.”</p>
<p>“I don’t flirt with them,” said Robina;
“I merely try to be nice to them.”</p>
<p>“With the exception of young Bute,” I
persisted.</p>
<p>“He irritates me,” Robina explained.</p>
<p>“I was reading,” I said, “the other day, an
account of the marriage customs prevailing among the Lower
Caucasians. The lover takes his stand beneath his
lady’s window, and, having attracted her attention,
proceeds to sing. And if she seems to like it—if she
listens to it without getting mad, that means she doesn’t
want him. But if she gets upset about it—slams down
the window and walks away, then it’s all right. I
think it’s the Lower Caucasians.”</p>
<p>“Must be a very silly people,” said Robina;
“I suppose a pail of water would be the highest proof of
her affection he could hope for.”</p>
<p>“A complex being, man,” I agreed. “We
will call him X. Can you imagine young X coming to you and
saying: ‘My dear Robina, you have many excellent
qualities. You can be amiable—so long as you are
having your own way in everything; but thwarted you can be just
horrid. You are very kind—to those who are willing
for you to be kind to them in your own way, which is not always
their way. You can be quite unselfish—when you happen
to be in an unselfish mood, which is far from frequent. You
are capable and clever, but, like most capable and clever people,
impatient and domineering; highly energetic when not feeling
lazy; ready to forgive the moment your temper is exhausted.
You are generous and frank, but if your object could only be
gained through meanness or deceit you would not hesitate a moment
longer than was necessary to convince yourself that the
circumstances justified the means. You are sympathetic,
tender-hearted, and have a fine sense of justice; but I can see
that tongue of yours, if not carefully watched, wearing decidedly
shrewish. You have any amount of grit. A man might go
tiger-hunting with you—with no one better; but you are
obstinate, conceited, and exacting. In short, to sum you
up, you have all the makings in you of an ideal wife combined
with faults sufficient to make a Socrates regret he’d ever
married you.’”</p>
<p>“Yes, I would!” said Robina, springing to her
feet. I could not see her face, but I knew there was the
look upon it that made Primgate want to paint her as Joan of Arc;
only it would never stop long enough. “I’d love
him for talking like that. And I’d respect him.
If he was that sort of man I’d pray God to help me to be
the sort of woman he wanted me to be. I’d try.
I’d try all day long. I would!”</p>
<p>“I wonder,” I said. Robina had surprised
me. I admit it. I thought I knew the sex better.</p>
<p>“Any girl would,” said Robina.
“He’d be worth it.”</p>
<p>“It would be a new idea,” I mused.
“<i>Gott im Himmel</i>! what a new world might it not
create!” The fancy began to take hold of me.
“Love no longer blind. Love refusing any more to be
the poor blind fool—sport of gods and men. Love no
longer passion’s slave. His bonds broken, the
senseless bandage flung aside. Love helping life instead of
muddling it. Marriage, the foundation of civilisation, no
longer reared upon the sands of lies and illusions, but grappled
to the rock of truth—reality. Have you ever read
‘Tom Jones?’” I said.</p>
<p>“No,” answered Robina; “I’ve always
heard it wasn’t a nice book.”</p>
<p>“It isn’t,” I said. “Man
isn’t a nice animal, not all of him. Nor woman
either. There’s a deal of the beast in man.
What can you expect? Till a few paltry thousands of years
ago he <i>was</i> a beast, fighting with other beasts, his fellow
denizens of the woods and caves; watching for his prey, crouched
in the long grass of the river’s bank, tearing it with
claws and teeth, growling as he ate. So he lived and died
through the dim unnamed ages, transmitting his beast’s
blood, his bestial instincts, to his offspring, growing ever
stronger, fiercer, from generation to generation, while the rocks
piled up their strata and the oceans shaped their beds.
Moses! Why, Lord Rothschild’s great-grandfather, a
few score times removed, must have known Moses, talked with
him. Babylon! It is a modern city, fallen into disuse
for the moment, owing to alteration of traffic routes.
History! it is a tale of to-day. Man was crawling about the
world on all fours, learning to be an animal for millions of
years before the secret of his birth was whispered to him.
It is only during the last few centuries that he has been trying
to be a man. Our modern morality! Why, compared with
the teachings of nature, it is but a few days old. What do
you expect? That he shall forget the lessons of the
æons at the bidding of the hours?”</p>
<p>“Then you advise me to read ‘Tom
Jones’?” said Robina.</p>
<p>“Yes,” I said, “I do. I should not if
I thought you were still a child, knowing only blind trust, or
blind terror. The sun is not extinguished because
occasionally obscured by mist; the scent of the rose is not dead
because of the worm in the leaf. A healthy rose can afford
a few worms—has got to, anyhow. All men are not Tom
Joneses. The standard of masculine behaviour continues to
go up: many of us make fine efforts to conform to it, and some of
us succeed. But the Tom Jones is there in all of us who are
not anæmic or consumptive. And there’s no sense
at all in getting cross with us about it, because we cannot help
it. We are doing our best. In another hundred
thousand years or so, provided all goes well, we shall be the
perfect man. And seeing our early training, I flatter
myself that, up to the present, we have done remarkably
well.”</p>
<p>“Nothing like being satisfied with oneself,” said
Robina.</p>
<p>“I’m not satisfied,” I said;
“I’m only hopeful. But it irritates me when I
hear people talk as though man had been born a white-souled angel
and was making supernatural efforts to become a sinner.
That seems to me the way to discourage him. What he wants
is bucking up; somebody to say to him, ‘Bravo! why, this is
splendid! Just think, my boy, what you were, and that not
so very long ago—an unwashed, hairy savage; your law that
of the jungle, your morals those of the rabbit-warren. Now
look at yourself—dressed in your little shiny hat, your
trousers neatly creased, walking with your wife to church on
Sunday! Keep on—that’s all you’ve got to
do. In a few more centuries your own mother Nature
won’t know you.’</p>
<p>“You women,” I continued; “why, a handful of
years ago we bought and sold you, kept you in cages, took the
stick to you when you were not spry in doing what you were
told. Did you ever read the history of Patient
Griselda?”</p>
<p>“Yes,” said Robina, “I have.” I
gathered from her tone that the Joan of Arc expression had
departed. Had Primgate wanted to paint her at that
particular moment I should have suggested Katherine—during
the earlier stages—listening to a curtain lecture from
Petruchio. “Are you suggesting that all women should
take her for a model?”</p>
<p>“No,” I said, “I’m not. Though
were we living in Chaucer’s time I might; and you would not
think it even silly. What I’m impressing upon you is
that the human race has yet a little way to travel before the
average man can be regarded as an up-to-date edition of King
Arthur—the King Arthur of the poetical legend, I
mean. Don’t be too impatient with him.”</p>
<p>“Thinking what a beast he has been ought to make him
impatient himself with himself,” considered Robina.
“He ought to be feeling so ashamed of himself as to be
willing to do anything.”</p>
<p>The owl in the old yew screamed, whether with indignation or
amusement I cannot tell.</p>
<p>“And woman,” I said, “had the power been
hers, would she have used it to sweeter purpose? Where is
your evidence? Your Cleopatras, Pompadours, Jezebels; your
Catherines of Russia, late Empresses of China; your Faustines of
all ages and all climes; your Mother Brownriggs; your Lucretia
Borgias, Salomes—I could weary you with names. Your
Roman task-mistresses; your drivers of lodging-house slaveys;
your ladies who whipped their pages to death in the Middle Ages;
your modern dames of fashion, decked with the plumage of the
tortured grove. There have been other women
also—noble women, their names like beacon-lights studding
the dark waste of history. So there have been noble
men—saints, martyrs, heroes. The sex-line divides us
physically, not morally. Woman has been man’s
accomplice in too many crimes to claim to be his judge.
‘Male and female created He them’—like and
like, for good and evil.”</p>
<p>By good fortune I found a loose match. I lighted a fresh
cigar.</p>
<p>“Dick, I suppose, is the average man,” said
Robina.</p>
<p>“Most of us are,” I said, “when we are at
home. Carlyle was the average man in the little front
parlour in Cheyne Row, though, to hear fools talk, you might
think no married couple outside literary circles had ever been
known to exchange a cross look. So was Oliver Cromwell in
his own palace with the door shut. Mrs. Cromwell must have
thought him monstrous silly, placing sticky sweetmeats for his
guests to sit on—told him so, most likely. A cheery,
kindly man, notwithstanding, though given to moods. He and
Mrs. Cromwell seem to have rubbed along, on the whole, pretty
well together. Old Sam Johnson—great, God-fearing,
lovable, cantankerous old brute! Life with him, in a small
house on a limited income, must have had its ups and downs.
Milton and Frederick the Great were, one hopes, a little below
the average. Did their best, no doubt; lacked
understanding. Not so easy as it looks, living up to the
standard of the average man. Very clever people, in
particular, find it tiring.”</p>
<p>“I shall never marry,” said Robina.
“At least, I hope I sha’n’t.”</p>
<p>“Why ‘hope’?” I asked.</p>
<p>“Because I hope I shall never be idiot enough,”
she answered. “I see it all so clearly. I wish
I didn’t. Love! it’s only an ugly thing with a
pretty name. It will not be me that he will fall in love
with. He will not know me until it is too late. How
can he? It will be merely with the outside of me—my
pink-and-white skin, my rounded arms. I feel it sometimes
when I see men looking at me, and it makes me mad. And at
other times the admiration in their eyes pleases me. And
that makes me madder still.”</p>
<p>The moon had slipped behind the wood. She had risen,
and, leaning against the porch, was standing with her hands
clasped. I fancy she had forgotten me. She seemed to
be talking to the night.</p>
<p>“It’s only a trick of Nature to make fools of
us,” she said. “He will tell me I am all the
world to him; that his love will outlive the stars—will
believe it himself at the time, poor fellow! He will call
me a hundred pretty names, will kiss my feet and hands. And
if I’m fool enough to listen to him, it may
last”—she laughed; it was rather an ugly
laugh—“six months; with luck perhaps a year, if
I’m careful not to go out in the east wind and come home
with a red nose, and never let him catch me in curl papers.
It will not be me that he will want: only my youth, and the
novelty of me, and the mystery. And when that is
gone—”</p>
<p>She turned to me. It was a strange face I saw then in
the pale light, quite a fierce little face. She laid her
hands upon my shoulders, and I felt them cold. “What
comes when it is dead?” she said. “What
follows? You must know. Tell me. I want the
truth.”</p>
<p>Her vehemence had arisen so suddenly. The little girl I
had set out to talk with was no longer there. To my
bewilderment, it was a woman that was questioning me.</p>
<p>I drew her down beside me. But the childish face was
still stern.</p>
<p>“I want the truth,” she said; so that I answered
very gravely:</p>
<p>“When the passion is passed; when the glory and the
wonder of Desire—Nature’s eternal ritual of marriage,
solemnising, sanctifying it to her commands—is ended; when,
sooner or later, some grey dawn finds you wandering bewildered in
once familiar places, seeking vainly the lost palace of
youth’s dreams; when Love’s frenzy is faded, like the
fragrance of the blossom, like the splendour of the dawn; there
will remain to you, just what was there before—no more, no
less. If passion was all you had to give to one another,
God help you. You have had your hour of madness. It
is finished. If greed of praise and worship was your
price—well, you have had your payment. The bargain is
complete. If mere hope to be made happy was your lure, one
pities you. We do not make each other happy.
Happiness is the gift of the gods, not of man. The secret
lies within you, not without. What remains to you will
depend not upon what you <i>thought</i>, but upon what you
<i>are</i>. If behind the lover there was the
man—behind the impossible goddess of his love-sick brain
some honest, human woman, then life lies not behind you, but
before you.</p>
<p>“Life is giving, not getting. That is the mistake
we most of us set out with. It is the work that is the joy,
not the wages; the game, not the score. The lover’s
delight is to yield, not to claim. The crown of motherhood
is pain. To serve the State at cost of ease and leisure; to
spend his thought and labour upon a hundred schemes, is the
man’s ambition. Life is doing, not having. It
is to gain the peak the climber strives, not to possess it.
Fools marry thinking what they are going to get out of it: good
store of joys and pleasure, opportunities for self-indulgence,
eternal soft caresses—the wages of the wanton. The
rewards of marriage are toil, duty, responsibility—manhood,
womanhood. Love’s baby talk you will have
outgrown. You will no longer be his ‘Goddess,’
‘Angel,’ ‘Popsy Wopsy,’ ‘Queen of
his heart.’ There are finer names than these: wife,
mother, priestess in the temple of humanity. Marriage is
renunciation, the sacrifice of Self upon the altar of the
race. ‘A trick of Nature’ you call it.
Perhaps. But a trick of Nature compelling you to surrender
yourself to the purposes of God.”</p>
<p>I fancy we must have sat in silence for quite a long while;
for the moon, creeping upward past the wood, had flooded the
fields again with light before Robina spoke.</p>
<p>“Then all love is needless,” she said, “we
could do better without it, choose with more discretion. If
it is only something that worries us for a little while and then
passes, what is the sense of it?”</p>
<p>“You could ask the same question of Life itself,”
I said; “‘something that worries us for a little
while, then passes.’ Perhaps the ‘worry,’
as you call it, has its uses. Volcanic upheavals are
necessary to the making of a world. Without them the ground
would remain rock-bound, unfitted for its purposes. That
explosion of Youth’s pent-up forces that we term Love
serves to the making of man and woman. It does not die, it
takes new shape. The blossom fades as the fruit
forms. The passion passes to give place to peace. The
trembling lover has become the helper, the comforter, the
husband.”</p>
<p>“But the failures,” Robina persisted; “I do
not mean the silly or the wicked people; but the people who begin
by really loving one another, only to end in
disliking—almost hating one another. How do
<i>they</i> get there?”</p>
<p>“Sit down,” I said, “and I will tell you a
story.</p>
<p>“Once upon a time there was a girl, and a boy who loved
her. She was a clever, brilliant girl, and she had the face
of an angel. They lived near to one another, seeing each
other almost daily. But the boy, awed by the difference of
their social position, kept his secret, as he thought, to
himself; dreaming, as youth will, of the day when fame and wealth
would bridge the gulf between them. The kind look in her
eyes, the occasional seeming pressure of her hand, he allowed to
feed his hopes; and on the morning of his departure for London an
incident occurred that changed his vague imaginings to set
resolve. He had sent on his scanty baggage by the carrier,
intending to walk the three miles to the station. It was
early in the morning, and he had not expected to meet a
soul. But a mile from the village he overtook her.
She was reading a book, but she made no pretence that the meeting
was accidental, leaving him to form what conclusions he
would. She walked with him some distance, and he told her
of his plans and hopes; and she answered him quite simply that
she should always remember him, always be more glad than she
could tell to hear of his success. Near the end of the lane
they parted, she wishing him in that low sweet woman’s
voice of hers all things good. He turned, a little farther
on, and found that she had also turned. She waved her hand
to him, smiling. And through the long day’s journey
and through many days to come there remained with him that
picture of her, bringing with it the scent of the pine-woods: her
white hand waving to him, her sweet eyes smiling wistfully.</p>
<p>“But fame and fortune are not won so quickly as boys
dream, nor is life as easy to live bravely as it looks in
visions. It was nearly twenty years before they met
again. Neither had married. Her people were dead and
she was living alone; and to him the world at last had opened her
doors. She was still beautiful. A gracious, gentle
lady, she had grown; clothed with that soft sweet dignity that
Time bestows upon rare women, rendering them fairer with the
years.</p>
<p>“To the man it seemed a miracle. The dream of
those early days came back to him. Surely there was nothing
now to separate them. Nothing had changed but the years,
bringing to them both wider sympathies, calmer, more enduring
emotions. She welcomed him again with the old kind smile, a
warmer pressure of the hand; and, allowing a little time to pass
for courtesy’s sake, he told her what was the truth: that
he had never ceased to love her, never ceased to keep the vision
of her fair pure face before him, his ideal of all that man could
find of help in womanhood. And her answer, until years
later he read the explanation, remained a mystery to him.
She told him that she loved him, that she had never loved any
other man and never should; that his love, for so long as he
chose to give it to her, she should always prize as the greatest
gift of her life. But with that she prayed him to remain
content.</p>
<p>“He thought perhaps it was a touch of woman’s
pride, of hurt dignity that he had kept silent so long, not
trusting her; that perhaps as time went by she would change her
mind. But she never did; and after awhile, finding that his
persistence only pained her, he accepted the situation. She
was not the type of woman about whom people talk scandal, nor
would it have troubled her much had they done so. Able now
to work where he would, he took a house in a neighbouring
village, where for the best part of the year he lived, near to
her. And to the end they remained lovers.”</p>
<p>“I think I understand,” said Robina.
“I will tell you afterwards if I am wrong.”</p>
<p>“I told the story to a woman many years ago,” I
said, “and she also thought she understood. But she
was only half right.”</p>
<p>“We will see,” said Robina. “Go
on.”</p>
<p>“She left a letter, to be given to him after her death,
in case he survived her; if not, to be burned unopened. In
it she told him her reason, or rather her reasons, for having
refused him. It was an odd letter. The
‘reasons’ sounded so pitiably insufficient.
Until one took the pains to examine them in the cold light of
experience. And then her letter struck one, not as foolish,
but as one of the grimmest commentaries upon marriage that
perhaps had ever been penned.</p>
<p>“It was because she had wished always to remain his
ideal; to keep their love for one another to the end,
untarnished; to be his true helpmeet in all things, that she had
refused to marry him.</p>
<p>“Had he spoken that morning she had waited for him in
the lane—she had half hoped, half feared it—she might
have given her promise: ‘For Youth,’ so she wrote,
‘always dreams it can find a new way.’ She
thanked God that he had not.</p>
<p>“‘Sooner or later,’ so ran the letter,
‘you would have learned, Dear, that I was neither saint nor
angel; but just a woman—such a tiresome, inconsistent
creature; she would have exasperated you—full of a thousand
follies and irritabilities that would have marred for you all
that was good in her. I wanted you to have of me only what
was worthy, and this seemed the only way. Counting the
hours to your coming, hating the pain of your going, I could
always give to you my best. The ugly words, the whims and
frets that poison speech—they could wait; it was my
lover’s hour.</p>
<p>“‘And you, Dear, were always so tender, so
gay. You brought me joy with both your hands. Would
it have been the same, had you been my husband? How could
it? There were times, even as it was, when you vexed
me. Forgive me, Dear, I mean it was my fault—ways of
thought and action that did not fit in with my ways, that I was
not large-minded enough to pass over. As my lover, they
were but as spots upon the sun. It was easy to control the
momentary irritation that they caused me. Time was too
precious for even a moment of estrangement. As my husband,
the jarring note would have been continuous, would have widened
into discord. You see, Dear, I was not great enough to love
<i>all</i> of you. I remember, as a child, how indignant I
always felt with God when my nurse told me He would not love me
because I was naughty, that He only loved good children. It
seemed such a poor sort of love, that. Yet that is
precisely how we men and women do love; taking only what gives us
pleasure, repaying the rest with anger. There would have
arisen the unkind words that can never be recalled; the ugly
silences; the gradual withdrawing from one another. I dared
not face it.</p>
<p>“‘It was not all selfishness. Truthfully I
can say I thought more of you than of myself. I wanted to
keep the shadows of life away from you. We men and women
are like the flowers. It is in sunshine that we come to our
best. You were my hero. I wanted you to be
great. I wanted you to be surrounded by lovely
dreams. I wanted your love to be a thing holy, helpful to
you.’</p>
<p>“It was a long letter. I have given you the gist
of it.”</p>
<p>Again there was a silence between us.</p>
<p>“You think she did right?” asked Robina.</p>
<p>“I cannot say,” I answered; “there are no
rules for Life, only for the individual.”</p>
<p>“I have read it somewhere,” said
Robina—“where was it?—‘Love suffers all
things, and rejoices.’”</p>
<p>“Maybe in old Thomas Kempis. I am not sure,”
I said.</p>
<p>“It seems to me,” said Robina, “that the
explanation lies in that one sentence of hers: ‘I was not
great enough to love <i>all</i> of you.’”</p>
<p>“It seems to me,” I said, “that the whole
art of marriage is the art of getting on with the other
fellow. It means patience, self-control, forbearance.
It means the laying aside of our self-conceit and admitting to
ourselves that, judged by eyes less partial than our own, there
may be much in us that is objectionable, that calls for
alteration. It means toleration for views and opinions
diametrically opposed to our most cherished convictions. It
means, of necessity, the abandonment of many habits and
indulgences that however trivial have grown to be important to
us. It means the shaping of our own desires to the needs of
others; the acceptance often of surroundings and conditions
personally distasteful to us. It means affection deep and
strong enough to bear away the ugly things of life—its
quarrels, wrongs, misunderstandings—swiftly and silently
into the sea of forgetfulness. It means courage, good
humour, commonsense.”</p>
<p>“That is what I am saying,” explained
Robina. “It means loving him even when he’s
naughty.”</p>
<p>Dick came across the fields. Robina rose and slipped
into the house.</p>
<p>“You are looking mighty solemn, Dad,” said
Dick.</p>
<p>“Thinking of Life, Dick,” I confessed.
“Of the meaning and the explanation of it.”</p>
<p>“Yes, it’s a problem, Life,” admitted
Dick.</p>
<p>“A bit of a teaser,” I agreed.</p>
<p>We smoked in silence for awhile.</p>
<p>“Loving a good woman must be a tremendous help to a
man,” said Dick.</p>
<p>He looked very handsome, very gallant, his boyish face
flashing challenge to the Fates.</p>
<p>“Tremendous, Dick,” I agreed.</p>
<p>Robina called to him that his supper was ready. He
knocked the ashes from his pipe, and followed her into the
house. Their laughing voices came to me broken through the
half-closed doors. From the night around me rose a strange
low murmur. It seemed to me as though above the silence I
heard the far-off music of the Mills of God.</p>
<div style="break-after:column;"></div><br />