<SPAN name="startofbook"></SPAN>
<h1>THE</h1>
<h1>WITNESS</h1>
<p class="center">A NOVEL</p>
<h3>BY</h3>
<h2>GRACE LIVINGSTON HILL LUTZ</h2>
<div class="center">AUTHOR OF<br/>
A VOICE IN THE WILDERNESS, <span class="smcap">Etc.</span></div>
<div class="figcenter"><ANTIMG src="./images/emblem.png" alt="Emblem" title="Emblem" /></div>
<div class="center">NEW YORK<br/>
<big>GROSSET & DUNLAP</big><br/>
PUBLISHERS</div>
<div class="center">Published by Arrangement with Harper & Brothers</div>
<div class="center"><small>Made in the United States of America</small></div>
<hr style='width: 45%;' />
<div class="center"><span class="smcap">The Witness</span></div>
<hr style='width: 15%;' />
<div class="center">Copyright, 1917, by Harper & Brothers<br/>
Printed in the United States of America</div>
<hr style='width: 45%;' />
<div class="center">TO MY MOTHER<br/>
<span class="smcap"><big>Marcia Macdonald Livingston</big></span></div>
<div class="center">WHOSE HELPFUL CRITICISM AND LOVING ENCOURAGEMENT<br/>
HAVE BEEN WITH ME THROUGH THE YEARS
<SPAN name="Page_0" id="Page_0"></SPAN></div>
<hr style='width: 45%;' />
<div class="blockquot"><i>"<big>H</big>e that believeth on the Son of God hath the witness in
himself."</i>
<p>—<span class="smcap">I John</span> 5:10</p>
</div>
<p><SPAN name="Page_1" id="Page_1"></SPAN></p>
<hr style="width: 65%;" />
<h2>Contents</h2>
<div class='center'>
<table border="0" cellpadding="1" cellspacing="0" summary="Contents">
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_I"><b>CHAPTER I</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_II"><b>CHAPTER II</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_III"><b>CHAPTER III</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_IV"><b>CHAPTER IV</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_V"><b>CHAPTER V</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_VI"><b>CHAPTER VI</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_VII"><b>CHAPTER VII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_VIII"><b>CHAPTER VIII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_IX"><b>CHAPTER IX</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_X"><b>CHAPTER X</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XI"><b>CHAPTER XI</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XII"><b>CHAPTER XII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XIII"><b>CHAPTER XIII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XIV"><b>CHAPTER XIV</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XV"><b>CHAPTER XV</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XVI"><b>CHAPTER XVI</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XVII"><b>CHAPTER XVII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XVIII"><b>CHAPTER XVIII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XIX"><b>CHAPTER XIX</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XX"><b>CHAPTER XX</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXI"><b>CHAPTER XXI</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXII"><b>CHAPTER XXII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXIII"><b>CHAPTER XXIII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXIV"><b>CHAPTER XXIV</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXV"><b>CHAPTER XXV</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXVI"><b>CHAPTER XXVI</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXVII"><b>CHAPTER XXVII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXVIII"><b>CHAPTER XXVIII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXIX"><b>CHAPTER XXIX</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXX"><b>CHAPTER XXX</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXXI"><b>CHAPTER XXXI</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXXII"><b>CHAPTER XXXII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXXIII"><b>CHAPTER XXXIII</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXXIV"><b>CHAPTER XXXIV</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXXV"><b>CHAPTER XXXV</b></SPAN></td></tr>
<tr><td align='left'><SPAN href="#CHAPTER_XXXVI"><b>CHAPTER XXXVI</b></SPAN></td></tr>
</table></div>
<hr style="width: 65%;" />
<h2>THE WITNESS</h2>
<hr style="width: 65%;" />
<h2><SPAN name="CHAPTER_I" id="CHAPTER_I"></SPAN>CHAPTER I</h2>
<p>Like a sudden cloudburst the dormitory had gone into a frenzy of sound.
Doors slammed, feet trampled, hoarse voices reverberated, heavy bodies
flung themselves along the corridor, the very electrics trembled with
the cataclysm. One moment all was quiet with a contented
after-dinner-peace-before-study hours; the next it was as if all the
forces of the earth had broken forth.</p>
<p>Paul Courtland stepped to his door and threw it back.</p>
<p>"Come on, Court, see the fun!" called the football half-back, who was
slopping along with two dripping fire-buckets of water.</p>
<p>"What's doing?"</p>
<p>"Swearing-match! Going to make Little Stevie cuss! Better get in on it.
Some fight! Tennelly sent 'Whisk' for a whole basket of superannuated
cackle-berries"—he motioned back to a freshman bearing a basket of
ancient eggs—"we're going to blindfold Steve and put oysters down his
back, and then finish up with the fire-hose. Oh, the seven plagues of
Egypt aren't in it with what we're going to do; and when we get done if
Little Stevie don't let out a string of good, <SPAN name="Page_2" id="Page_2"></SPAN>honest cuss-words like a
man then I'll eat my hat. Little Stevie's got good stuff in him if it
can only be brought out. We're a-going to bring it out. Then we're going
to celebrate by taking him over to the theater and making him see 'The
Scarlet Woman.' It'll be a little old miracle, all right, if he has any
of his whining Puritanical ideas left in him after we get through with
him. Come on! Get on the job!"</p>
<p>Drifting along with the surging tide of students, Courtland sauntered
down the corridor to the door at the extreme end where roomed the
victim.</p>
<p>He rather liked Stephen Marshall. There was good stuff in him; all the
fellows recognized that. Only he was woefully unsophisticated,
abnormally innocent, frankly religious, and a little too openly white in
his life. It seemed a rebuke to the other fellows, unconscious though it
might be. He felt with the rest that the fellow needed a lesson.
Especially since the bald way in which he had dared to stand up for the
old-fashioned view of miracles in biblical-lit. class that morning. Of
course an ignorance like that wouldn't go down, and it was best he
should learn it at once and get to be a good fellow without loss of
time. A little gentle rubbing off of the "mamma's-good-little-boy"
veneering would do him good. He wasn't sure but with such a course
Marshall might even be eligible for the frat. that year. He sauntered
along with his hands in his pockets; a handsome, capable, powerful
figure; not taking any part in the preparations, but mildly interested
in the plans. His presence lent enthusiasm to the gathering. He was high
in authority. A star athlete, an A student, president of his fraternity,
having made the Phi Beta Kappa in his junior year, and now in his senior
year being chairman of the student exec. There would be no trouble with
the <SPAN name="Page_3" id="Page_3"></SPAN>authorities of the college if Court was along to give countenance.</p>
<p>Courtland stood opposite the end door when it was unceremoniously thrust
open and the hilarious mob rushed in. From his position with his back
against the wall he could see Stephen lift his fine head from his book
and rise to greet them. There was surprise and a smile of welcome on his
face. Courtland thought it almost a pity to reward such open-heartedness
as they were about to do; but such things were necessary in the making
of men. He watched developments with interest.</p>
<p>A couple of belated participants in the fray arrived breathlessly,
shedding their mackinaws as they ran, and casting them down at
Courtland's feet.</p>
<p>"Look after those, will you, Court? We've got to get in on this,"
shouted one as he thrust a noisy bit of flannel head-gear at Courtland.</p>
<p>Courtland gave the garments a kick behind him and stood watching.</p>
<p>There was a moment's tense silence while they told the victim what they
had come for, and while the light of welcome in Stephen Marshall's eyes
melted and changed into lightning. A dart of it went with a searching
gleam out into the hall, and seemed to recognize Courtland as he stood
idly smiling, watching the proceedings. Then the lightning was withheld
in the gray eyes, and Marshall seemed to conclude that, after all, the
affair must be a huge kind of joke, seeing Courtland was out there.
Courtland had been friendly. He must not let his temper rise. The kindly
light came into the eyes again, and for an instant Marshall almost
disarmed the boldest of them with his brilliant smile. He would be game
as far as he understood. That was plain. It was equally plain that he
did not understand yet what was expected of him. <SPAN name="Page_4" id="Page_4"></SPAN></p>
<p>Pat McCluny, thick of neck, brutal of jaw, low-browed, red of face,
blunt of speech, the finest, most unmerciful tackler on the football
team, stepped up to Stephen and said a few words in a low tone.
Courtland could not hear what they were save that they ended with an
oath, the choicest of Pat McCluny's choice collection.</p>
<p>Instantly Stephen Marshall drew himself back, and up to his great
height, lightning and thunder-clouds in his gray eyes, his powerful arms
folded, his fine head crowned with its wealth of beautiful gold hair
thrown a trifle back and up, his lips shut in a thin, firm line, his
whole attitude that of the fighter; but he did not speak. He only looked
from one to another of the wild young mob, searching for a friend; and,
finding none, he stood firm, defying them all. There was something
splendid in his bearing that sent a thrill of admiration down
Courtland's spine as he watched, his habitual half-cynical smile of
amusement still lying unconsciously about his lips, while a new respect
for the country student was being born in his heart.</p>
<p>Pat, with a half-lowering of his bullet head, and a twisting of his ugly
jaw, came a step nearer and spoke again, a low word with a rumble like
the menace of a bull or a storm about to break.</p>
<p>With a sudden unexpected movement Stephen's arm shot forth and struck
the fellow in the jaw, reeling him half across the room into the crowd.</p>
<p>With a snarl like a stung animal Pat recovered himself and rushed at
Stephen, hurling himself with a stream of oaths, and calling curses down
upon himself if he did not make Stephen utter worse before he was done
with him. Pat was the "man" who was in college for football. It took the
united efforts of his classmates, his frat., and the faculty to keep his
studies <SPAN name="Page_5" id="Page_5"></SPAN>within decent hailing distance of eligibility for playing. He
came from a race of bullies whose culture was all in their fists.</p>
<p>Pat went straight for the throat of his victim. His fighting blood was
up and he was mad clear down to the bone. Nobody could give him a blow
like that in the presence of others and not suffer for it. What had
started as a joke had now become real with Pat; and the frenzy of his
own madness quickly spread to those daring spirits who were about him
and who disliked Stephen for his strength of character.</p>
<p>They clinched, and Stephen, fresh from his father's remote Western farm,
matched his mighty, untaught strength against the trained bully of a
city street.</p>
<p>For a moment there was dead silence while the crowd in breathless
astonishment watched and held in check their own eagerness. Then the mob
spirit broke forth as some one called out:</p>
<p>"Pray for a miracle, Stevie! Pray for a miracle! You'll need it, old
boy!"</p>
<p>The mad spirit which had incited them to the reckless fray broke forth
anew and a medley of shouts arose.</p>
<p>"Jump in, boys! Now's the time!"</p>
<p>"Give him a cowardly egg or two—the kind that hits and runs!"</p>
<p>"Teach him that we will be obeyed!"</p>
<p>The latter came as a sort of chant, and was reiterated at intervals
through the pandemonium of sound.</p>
<p>The fight raged on for minutes more, and still Stephen stood with his
back against the wall, fighting, gasping, struggling, but bravely facing
them all; a disheveled object with rotten eggs streaming from his face
and hair, his clothes plastered with offensive yolks. Pat had him by the
throat, but still he stood and fought as best he could. <SPAN name="Page_6" id="Page_6"></SPAN></p>
<p>Some one seized the bucket of water and deluged both. Some one else
shouted, "Get the hose!" and more fellows tore off their coats and threw
them down at Courtland's feet; some one tore Pat away, and the great
fire-hose was turned upon the victim.</p>
<p>Gasping at last, and all but unconscious, he was set upon his feet, and
harried back to life again. Over-powered by numbers, he could do
nothing, and the petty torments that were applied amid a round of
ringing laughter seemed unlimited; but still he stood, a man among them,
his lips closed, a firm set about his jaw that showed their labor was in
vain so far as making him obey their command was concerned. Not one word
had he uttered since they entered his room.</p>
<p>"You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink," shouted
one onlooker. "Cut it out, fellows! It's no use! You can't set him
cussing. He never learned how. He could easier lead in prayer. You have
to teach him how. Better cut it out!"</p>
<p>More tortures were applied, but still the victim was silent. The hose
had washed him clean again, and his face shone white from the drenching.
Some one suggested it was getting late and the show would begin. Some
one else suggested they must dress up Little Stevie for his first play.
There was a mad rush for garments. Any garments, no matter whose. A pair
of sporty trousers, socks of brilliant colors—not mates, an old
football shoe on one foot, a dancing-pump on the other, a white vest and
a swallow-tail put on backward, collar and tie also backward, a large
pair of white-cotton gloves commonly used by workmen for rough
work—Johnson, who earned his way in college by tending furnaces,
furnished these. Stephen bore it all, grim, unflinching, until they set
him up before his mirror and let him see himself, completing <SPAN name="Page_7" id="Page_7"></SPAN>the
costume by a high silk hat crammed down upon his wet curls. He looked at
the guy he was and suddenly he turned upon them and smiled, his broad,
merry smile! <i>After all that</i> he could see the joke and smile! He never
opened his lips nor spoke—just smiled.</p>
<p>"He's a pretty good guy! He's game, all right!" murmured some one in
Courtland's ear. And then, half shamedly, they caught him high upon
their shoulders and bore him down the stairs and out the door.</p>
<p>The theater was some distance off. They bore down upon a trolley-car and
took a wild possession. They sang their songs and yelled themselves
hoarse. People turned and watched and smiled, setting this down as one
more prank of those university fellows.</p>
<p>They swarmed into the theater, with Stephen in their midst, and took
noisy occupancy. Opera-glasses were turned their way, and the girls
nudged one another and talked about the man in the middle with the queer
garments.</p>
<p>The persecutions had by no means ceased because they had landed their
victim in a public place. They made him ridiculous at every breath. They
took off his hat, arranged his collar, and smoothed his hair as if he
were a baby. They wiped his nose with many a flourishing handkerchief,
and pointed out objects of interest about the theater in open derision
of his supposed ignorance, to the growing amusement of those of the
audience who were their neighbors. And when the curtain rose on the most
notoriously flagrant play the city boasted, they added to its flagrance
by their whispered explanations and remarks.</p>
<p>Stephen, in his ridiculous garb, sat in their midst, a prisoner, and
watched the play he would not have chosen to see; watched it with a face
of growing in<SPAN name="Page_8" id="Page_8"></SPAN>dignation; a face so speaking in its righteous wrath that
those about who saw him turned to look again, and somehow felt condemned
for being there.</p>
<p>Sometimes a wave of anger would sweep over the young man, and he would
turn to look about him with an impulse to suddenly break away and
attempt to defy them all. But his every movement was anticipated, and he
had the whole football team about him! There was no chance to move. He
must stay it through, much as he disliked it. He must stand it in spite
of the tumult of rage in his heart. He was not smiling now. His face had
that set, grim look of the faithful soldier taken prisoner and tortured
to give information about his army's plans. Stephen's eyes shone true,
and his lips were set firmly together.</p>
<p>"Just one nice little cuss-word and we'll take you home," whispered a
tormentor. "A single little word will do, just to show you are a man."</p>
<p>Stephen's face was gray with determination. His yellow hair shone like a
halo about his head. They had taken off his hat and he sat with his arms
folded fiercely across the back of "Andy" Roberts's nifty evening coat.</p>
<p>"Just one little real cuss to show you are a <i>man</i>," sneered the
freshman.</p>
<p>But suddenly a smothered cry arose. A breath of fear stirred through the
house. The smell of smoke swept in from a sudden open door. The actors
paused, grew white, and swerved in their places; then one by one fled
out of the scene. The audience arose and turned to panic, even as a
flame swept up and licked the very curtain while it fell.</p>
<p>All was confusion!</p>
<p>The football team, trained to meet emergencies, forgot their cruel play
and scattered, over seats and <SPAN name="Page_9" id="Page_9"></SPAN>railing, everywhere, to fire-escapes and
doorways, taking command of wild, stampeding people, showing their
training and their courage.</p>
<p>Stephen, thus suddenly set free, glanced about him, and saw a few feet
away an open door, felt the fresh breeze of evening upon his hot
forehead, and knew the upper back fire-escape was close at hand. By some
strange whim of a panic-maddened crowd but few had discovered this exit,
high above the seats in the balcony; for all had rushed below and were
struggling in a wild, frantic mass, trampling one another underfoot in a
mad struggle to reach the doorways. The flames were sweeping over the
platform now, licking out into the very pit of the theater, and people
were terrified. Stephen saw in an instant that the upper door, being
farthest away from the center of the fire, was the place of greatest
safety. With one frantic leap he gained the aisle, strode up to the
doorway, glanced out into the night to take in the situation; cool,
calm, quiet, with the still stars overhead, down below the open iron
stairway of the fire-escape, and a darkened street with people like tiny
puppets moving on their way. Then turning back, he tore off the
grotesque coat and vest, the confining collar, and threw them from him.
He plunged down the steps of the aisle to the railing of the gallery,
and, leaning there in his shirt-sleeves and the queer striped trousers,
he put his hands like a megaphone about his lips and shouted:</p>
<p>"Look up! Look up! There is a way to escape up here! Look up!"</p>
<p>Some poor struggling ones heard him and looked up. A little girl was
held up by her father to the strong arms reached out from the low front
of the balcony. Stephen caught her and swung her up beside him, pointing
her up to the door, and shouting to her to go <SPAN name="Page_10" id="Page_10"></SPAN>quickly down the
fire-escape, even while he reached out his other hand to catch a woman,
whom willing hands below were lifting up. Men climbed upon the seats and
vaulted up when they heard the cry and saw the way of safety; and some
stayed and worked bravely beside Stephen, wrenching up the seats and
piling them for a ladder to help the women up. More just clambered up
and fled to the fire-escape, out into the night and safety.</p>
<p>But Stephen had no thought of flight. He stayed where he was, with
aching back, cracking muscles, sweat-grimed brow, and worked, his breath
coming in quick, sharp gasps as he frantically helped man, woman, child,
one after another, like sheep huddling over a flood.</p>
<p>Courtland was there.</p>
<p>He had lingered a moment behind the rest in the corner of the dormitory
corridor, glancing into the disfigured room; water, egg-shells, ruin,
disorder everywhere! A little object on the floor, a picture in a cheap
oval metal frame, caught his eye. Something told him it was the picture
of Stephen Marshall's mother that he had seen upon the student's desk a
few days before, when he had sauntered in to look the new man over.
Something unexplained made him step in across the water and debris and
pick it up. It was the picture, still unscarred, but with a great streak
of rotten egg across the plain, placid features. He recalled the tone in
which the son had pointed out the picture and said, "That's my mother!"
and again he followed an impulse and wiped off the smear, setting the
picture high on the shelf, where it looked down upon the depredation
like some hallowed saint above a carnage.</p>
<p>Then Courtland sauntered on to his room, completed his toilet, and
followed to the theater. He had not <SPAN name="Page_11" id="Page_11"></SPAN>wanted to get mixed up too much in
the affair. He thought the fellows were going a little too far with a
good thing, perhaps. He wanted to see it through, but still he would not
quite mix with it. He found a seat where he could watch what was going
on without being actually a part of it. If anything should come to the
ears of the faculty he wanted to be on the side of conservatism always.
That Pat McCluny was not just his sort, though he was good fun. But he
always put things on a lower level than college fellows should go.
Besides, if things went too far a word from himself would check them.</p>
<p>Courtland was rather bored with the play, and was almost on the point of
going back to study when the cry arose and panic followed.</p>
<p>Courtland was no coward. He tore off his handsome overcoat and rushed to
meet the emergency. On the opposite side of the gallery, high up by
another fire-escape he rendered efficient assistance to many.</p>
<p>The fire was gaining in the pit; and still there were people down there,
swarms of them, struggling, crying, lifting piteous hands for
assistance. Still Stephen Marshall reached from the gallery and pulled
up, one after another, poor creatures, and still the helpless thronged
and cried for aid.</p>
<p>Dizzy, blinded, his eyes filled with smoke, his muscles trembling with
the terrible strain, he stood at his post. The minutes seemed
interminable hours, and still he worked, with heart pumping painfully,
and mind that seemed to have no thought save to reach down for another
and another, and point up to safety.</p>
<p>Then, into the midst of the confusion there arose an instant of great
and awful silence. One of those silences that come even into great sound
and claim attention from the most absorbed. <SPAN name="Page_12" id="Page_12"></SPAN></p>
<p>Paul Courtland, high in his chosen station, working eagerly,
successfully, calmly, looked down to see the cause of this sudden
arresting of the universe; and there, below, was the pit full of flame,
with people struggling and disappearing into fiery depths below. Just
above the pit stood Stephen, lifting aloft a little child with
frightened eyes and long streaming curls. He swung him high and turned
to stoop again; then with his stooping came the crash; the rending,
grinding, groaning, twisting of all that held those great galleries in
place, as the fire licked hold of their supports and wrenched them out
of position.</p>
<p>One instant Stephen was standing by that crimson-velvet railing, with
his lifted hand pointing the way to safety for the child, the flaming
fire lighting his face with glory, his hair a halo about his head, and
in the next instant, even as his hand was held out to save another, the
gallery fell, crashing into the fiery, burning furnace! And Stephen,
with his face shining like an angel's, went down and disappeared with
the rest, while the consuming fire swept up and covered them.</p>
<p>Paul Courtland closed his eyes on the scene, and caught hold of the door
by which he stood. He did not realize that he was standing on a tiny
ledge, all that was left him of footing, high, alone, above that burning
pit where his fellow-student had gone down; nor that he had escaped as
by a miracle. There he stood and turned away his face, sick and dizzy
with the sight, blinded by the dazzling flames, shut in to that tiny
spot by a sudden wall of smoke that swept in about him. Yet in all the
danger and the horror the only thought that came was, "God! <i>That</i> was a
<i>man</i>!" <SPAN name="Page_13" id="Page_13"></SPAN></p>
<hr style="width: 65%;" />
<div style="break-after:column;"></div><br />